Although I’ve tried on many events to articulate the distinction between TiVo, Tablo, HDHomeRun, and different over-the-air DVR options, one can solely accomplish that a lot with written descriptions.
Over-the-air DVR can shortly develop into sophisticated. If you need to document free broadcast channels from an antenna, you may have to string collectively separate tuner bins, arduous drives, antennas, and streaming gamers. While I’m a wordsmith at coronary heart—a truth that ought to quickly develop into obvious from my drawing abilities—the idea is admittedly simpler to clarify with photos.
So let’s just do that. Below is an illustrated information to the best and most popular DVR options for cord-cutters, with some further textual content descriptions the place relevant.
TiVo
TiVo DVRs such because the Edge and Bolt OTA are the simplest to grasp: Just plug in an antenna, then join them to your TV with an HDMI cable, identical to you’d with a cable field.
The downside with TiVo’s strategy is twofold:
- As a streaming gadget, TiVo solely affords a small choice of apps, together with Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Hulu. That means you’ll want a separate gadget (resembling a Roku player or Amazon Fire TV Stick) for many different streaming sources, together with Disney+, Tubi, Pluto TV, or Peacock. Also, you’ll be always switching forwards and backwards between inputs.
- Accessing your TiVo DVR on extra televisions requires a TiVo Mini extender linked to every TV. The present TiVo Mini Lux prices $200 per field and have to be hard-wired to your Wi-Fi router except you spend an additional $60 per extender on Wi-Fi adapters. This type of funding is ill-advised given TiVo’s fading interest in DVR.
Illustrated beneath are some trendy whole-home DVR choices that remedy each issues.
Tablo
Jared Newman / IDGHere’s the only solution to describe Nuvyyo’s Tablo DVRs: They’re whole-home DVRs that you simply entry by your good TV or streaming participant. Instead of connecting on to your TV, the Tablo streams video over Wi-Fi to the Tablo app, which you’ll obtain on a wide range of devices.
With this strategy, there’s virtually no restrict on the place you may entry your DVR. And as a result of the Tablo app is offered on streaming gamers and good TVs, you don’t want to change inputs to make use of different streaming companies, resembling Netflix or Disney+.
Depending on which Tablo model you buy, nevertheless, you may want to provide your individual arduous drive. Some fashions have inside storage built-in; others don’t.
Fire TV Recast
Jared Newman / IDGThe concept behind Amazon’s Fire TV Recast DVR is similar as that of Tablo: It captures broadcast channels from an antenna, then streams the video to different gadgets over your Wi-Fi community. Again, it doesn’t plug instantly into your tv.
The essential distinction is that the Recast requires a Fire TV gadget to look at in your tv. That could possibly be a Fire TV Stick, a Fire TV Cube, or a Fire TV Edition good tv. It’s incompatible with different streaming gadgets resembling Roku gamers or Apple TV.
On the upside, the Recast is deeply built-in with Fire TV in ways in which different over-the-air DVRs should not. You can tune to stay channels utilizing Alexa voice instructions, as an illustration, and there’s a channel guide built right into the Fire TV menu system. It’s price contemplating if you happen to’re all-in on the Fire TV platform already.
AirTV
Jared Newman / IDGLike Tablo and Amazon’s Fire TV Recast, AirTV streams broadcast TV to different gadgets round the home. But this networked tuner places a novel spin on the whole-home over-the-air DVR idea.
Instead of supplying its personal app, AirTV integrates with the Sling TV app on Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Android TV, and Apple TV. If you’re a Sling TV subscriber, meaning you may get over-the-air and cable channels by a single app and TV information.
One factor to notice: While the fundamental AirTV 2 tuner requires you to attach an exterior arduous drive, the not too long ago introduced AirTV Anywhere has a 1TB drive inbuilt.
Plex and Channels
Jared Newman / IDGPlex and Channels are basically do-it-yourself DVRs, utilizing an HDHomeRun tuner to seize broadcast channels and a media server gadget to document them. The server is usually a desktop laptop, NAS field, Nvidia Shield TV Pro, or (if you’re up for an additional challenge) Raspberry Pi micro-computer. Like the opposite whole-home DVRs above, you’ll use a separate streaming gadget to look at stay or recorded TV. (Plex additionally helps several other tuners in addition to HDHomeRun.)
The setup is clearly extra onerous than the opposite choices I’ve described, partly as a result of there’s extra {hardware} concerned, and partly as a result of the HDHomeRun tuner requires a wired connection to your router. But each Plex and Channels are superior at preserving the total high quality of broadcast TV, and so they offer you extra flexibility over how and the place your recordings are saved. Channels DVR additionally has the power to record certain live streaming sources, so that you’re not simply restricted to what’s broadcasting over the air, and Plex gives a full-blown media server that may stream your private music, film, TV present collections to different gadgets round the home. These further options make them nice choices for energy customers.
Keep in thoughts that HDHomeRun does offer its own DVR service, which might run instantly on its Scribe and Servio tuners with out a separate media server gadget. It’s not almost as polished or highly effective as Plex or Channels, although.
No DVR
Jared Newman / IDGA standard false impression in cord-cutting is that you simply want one in every of these options within the first place. While an over-the-air DVR can give you heaps to look at at a low value, it’s hardly the one solution to lower the wire.
Live TV streaming services resembling YouTube TV, Hulu + Live TV, and Sling TV all provide bundles of channels past what you may get over the air, and so they all embody their very own cloud-based DVR companies. Meanwhile, standalone streaming companies like Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Disney+ provide big catalogs of on-demand video, rendering DVR redundant.
So don’t despair if over-the-air DVR appears too sophisticated or if you happen to’re unable to obtain broadcast channels from an antenna. It’s only one strategy amongst many.
Sign up for Jared’s Cord Cutter Weekly newsletter to get this column and different cord-cutting information, insights, and offers delivered to your inbox.