As inflation soars, Facebook drives trading in Argentina’s barter clubs

    SAN MIGUEL, Argentina (Reuters) – At an deserted prepare station in Buenos Aires’ working-class suburb of San Miguel, lots of of Argentines collect with baggage of garments, rice, flour and sugar to commerce.

    Most are girls, some accompanied by kids. Cardboard indicators with their names scrawled in black marker hold from strings round their necks. They stroll slowly across the previous concrete platform yelling out the names of individuals they’d agreed to commerce with in a discussion board on Fb (FB.O).

    They’re the face of a resurgent however little-reported phenomenon within the suburbs surrounding the Argentine capital – barter golf equipment.

    The golf equipment have tens of 1000’s of members and are attracting lots of extra each week. They’ve change into an unofficial financial indicator, exhibiting the toll that hovering inflation and excessive unemployment are exacting on South America’s second-biggest economic system.

    The barter golf equipment have surfaced earlier than, throughout Argentina’s 2001-2002 financial disaster and within the 2009 world monetary meltdown. In between these crises they by no means fully went away, however immediately the golf equipment function otherwise. Many members are a part of Fb teams the place they prepare trades earlier than exchanging items in individual at locations just like the railway station.

    Membership within the golf equipment has been hovering in latest months as poor Argentines, a lot of whom have misplaced their jobs or work off-the-books, battle to search out the money to make ends meet. They’re one signal that progress made by President Mauricio Macri final yr in lowering poverty is starting to reverse.

    The nation’s inflation fee is working at above 25 p.c, and the foreign money has misplaced greater than 30 p.c of its worth this yr in a monetary disaster that economists say will seemingly set off a recession.

    With unemployment working at 9.1 p.c and plenty of salaries chewed up by years of excessive inflation, members of the barter golf equipment deliver second-hand items, rice or home made produce like desserts to commerce.

    A chart posted on the San Miguel group’s Fb web page outlines a factors system for sure items. It’s aimed toward making certain contributors really feel their trades are truthful.

    A 1 kg (2 lb) pack of flour serves as a reference, with a hypothetical worth of 30 pesos, or one level. Two packs of flour are price one bottle of sunflower oil. 4 packs of flour is the prompt worth for one cake, whereas three packs can be utilized to get grownup denims.

    When Reuters visited the San Miguel market and one in Merlo, one other Buenos Aires suburb, most individuals gave the impression to be leaving with meals.


    Cecilia Gómez, whose husband misplaced his job at a struggling restaurant in February, was amongst these buying and selling on the market.

    “This helps me deliver my youngsters milk, sugar: the issues which are most crucial,” she mentioned.

    Her husband spent a number of months working as a cartonero, the native time period for individuals who sift by trash bins for recyclable items, earlier than discovering a brand new job at a grocery retailer final month. He earns simply 10,000 pesos ($350) per thirty days, far lower than his earlier wage.

    Gómez additionally receives a 1,000 peso-per-month subsidy from a authorities welfare program for every of her two kids, however after paying Three,700 pesos per thirty days for hire and 1,200 pesos for her husband’s journey to work, there may be not sufficient money left for primary items.

    Just lately, the 30-year-old housewife noticed a submit on the San Miguel barter membership’s Fb web page providing up a pair of shoes in trade for a zero.9 liter bottle cooking oil, two packets of sugar and three packs of crackers.

    Gómez desperately wanted the boots and accepted the supply although she didn’t even have any of the objects the poster needed.

    So she made a submit of her personal asking for these objects, and providing in return some used garments and a bottle of cologne she had purchased for her 9-year-old son that he had by no means opened. After one other member accepted the supply, she made each trades in individual on the market.

    Slideshow (11 Pictures)

    She additionally introduced home made muffins and alfajores, a shortbread-based deal with, to commerce in trade for some milk, flour, oil and sugar to deliver house. That commerce was additionally organized on Fb.


    Barter golf equipment aren’t distinctive to Argentina. Related golf equipment have popped up throughout financial crises elsewhere, comparable to in rural Greece in 2015 after Athens defaulted on an Worldwide Financial Fund mortgage and shut down banks to stop a run on deposits.

    The casual nature of bartering teams in Argentina means their development is troublesome to trace.  A spokesman for Argentina’s Social Growth Ministry declined to touch upon the rise in barter golf equipment.    

    However Jesica Galera, founding father of a Fb barter group referred to as ‘Cambio x Mercaderia’, mentioned her group is receiving 50-60 new members per day.

    “There are a lot of new faces – girls whose husbands misplaced their jobs, or these who each work and their wages aren’t sufficient,” mentioned Galera, who based the 30,000-member group in April 2016.

    The victory of Macri’s ‘Let’s Change’ coalition in midterm congressional elections final October was due partly to improved assist amongst residents within the sprawling, working-class suburbs of Buenos Aires, the place the barter golf equipment are principally based mostly. His efficiency raised the chance that Macri can be re-elected in subsequent yr’s presidential election.

    Since then, nevertheless, 1000’s of Argentines have taken to the streets to protest rises of as much as 40 p.c in utility payments, a part of Macri’s plan to chop the federal government’s price range deficit by trimming subsidies for gasoline and electrical energy.

    Greater rates of interest of as much as 40 p.c which are supposed to stem the autumn within the worth of the nation’s foreign money, the peso, have reduce off entry to finance for a lot of companies. Greater than 5,000 small and mid-sized companies have closed up to now two years, based on the federal government.

    Because the peso misplaced worth towards different currencies in latest months, it turned costlier for Argentina to pay its money owed, that are largely denominated in U.S. or euros. So Macri turned to the IMF in Could for monetary assist.

    Many within the Buenos Aires space are feeling the pinch from the rise in inflation that has resulted from the foreign money depreciation.

    “The cash shouldn’t be sufficient,” mentioned Silvia Aranda, the administrator of a barter membership with 46,000 Fb members in Merlo, a suburb of the river-front capital with greater than 500,000 residents. “Earlier than, we have been getting 100 requests to hitch per day. Now, it’s much more.”


    Rising inflation this yr has had the most important affect on the roughly 20 p.c of Argentine staff who work irregular, off-the-books jobs, mentioned Agustin Salvia, a researcher on the Catholic College of Argentina.

    These staff, who don’t profit from union bargaining agreements that maintain salaries above inflation and infrequently discover themselves with out work throughout financial slowdowns, make up the majority of barter membership members, Salvia mentioned.

    Knowledge revealed by Salvia’s Argentine Observatory of Social Debt reveals that almost 29 p.c of individuals have been under the poverty line in 2017, down from practically 33 p.c in 2016 and practically 30 p.c in 2015, however the identical because the practically 29 p.c registered in 2014. Salvia mentioned he expects a rise of 2-Three share factors within the poverty fee this yr.

    However Galera, the organizer of the San Miguel market, doesn’t want to attend for the brand new poverty knowledge to know that persons are hurting. With increasingly individuals attending her market, she mentioned she plans to ask municipal authorities to grant her a allow for a bigger area to commerce in.

    And housewife Cecilia Gómez shall be returning to the market on Friday, once more laden along with her home made alfajores. She’s hoping to commerce them for milk, detergent and ‘yerba,’ the bitter herb base for Argentina’s signature ‘mate’ infusion.

    “That’s what I would like urgently at house,” she mentioned.

    Reporting by Nicolas Misculin; Writing by Luc Cohen; Modifying by Daniel Flynn and Ross Colvin

    Recent Articles

    Related Stories

    Stay on op - Ge the daily news in your inbox