Last Friday, the Federal Communications Commission lastly gave up on making an attempt to mandate extra alternate options to clunky and costly cable containers.
In a unanimous decision, the company eradicated guidelines requiring cable suppliers to help CableCARD units, that are used at this time in third-party DVRs resembling TiVo. It additionally formally terminated a four-year-old proposal that might have opened the door to much more cable-box competitors.
The FCC’s determination was on some degree only a formality. CableCARD has lengthy been a uncared for know-how amongst customers, and the proposal to “unlock” the cable field dates again to the Obama-era FCC, which was rather more adversarial towards TV suppliers than the present fee. But it’s additionally a tragic reminder of how even within the streaming period, cable and satellite tv for pc TV prospects have little alternative over what {hardware} they will use. The FCC has now reiterated that it’s now not involved in doing something about it.
CableCARD’s lengthy goodbye
Providing cable prospects with extra {hardware} alternative was the unique objective of CableCARD, a government-mandated resolution that allow customers securely entry cable programming on third-party {hardware}. TiVo’s cable DVRs all use CableCARD, as do another units resembling SiliconDust’s HDHomeRun Prime and Hauppauge’s WinTV-DCRs.
Until final week, the FCC required cable firms to lease CableCARDs that prospects may set up themselves, and with none value discrimination that might render them price -prohibitive. Cable firms additionally needed to report back to the FCC on their deployments of CableCARD to make sure they have been following the foundations. Satellite TV service suppliers, in the meantime, have been by no means held to comparable guidelines.
The FCC now says these guidelines are now not crucial, partially as a result of individuals can simply use streaming units to entry pay TV content material as an alternative. The company claimed that streaming apps from cable and satellite tv for pc TV suppliers at the moment are “ubiquitous,” (a doubtful declare, as I’ll talk about shortly) and that buyers have “demonstrated a clear preference” for these apps over CableCARD. Only 456,000 CableCARD units have been deployed in retail units like TiVo as of Q1 2020, down from 509,000 units two years earlier.
CableCARD permits third-party DVRs like TiVo to work with digital cable programming.
This doesn’t imply CableCARD will vanish in a single day. The FCC believes that cable firms will hold supporting the know-how, each as a result of they don’t need to lose extra subscribers and since hundreds of thousands of their very own cable containers even have CableCARDs inside. (That’s as a result of cable firms have been required to make use of the know-how in their very own {hardware} till Congress repealed the CableCARD mandate in 2015.)
Still, it gained’t be shocking if cable firms begin charging extra for the privilege of utilizing CableCARD or making them more durable to get for brand new subscribers. We’ll additionally doubtless see fewer CableCARD merchandise available on the market going ahead. TiVo already appears mentally checked out of the consumer DVR business, and Nick Kelsey, the CTO of SiliconDust, instructed me through electronic mail that whereas the corporate will nonetheless help CableCARD prospects, it’s now investing closely in ATSC 3.0 hardware, each for cable and over-the-air TV. (Pressed about whether or not the corporate will hold making CableCARD merchandise, Kelsey stated it’s “still being discussed internally.”)
The unlocked field that wasn’t
Four years in the past, the FCC appeared to understand that CableCARD was an inadequate various to cable containers.
Under the FCC’s earlier chairman, Tom Wheeler, the company proposed a new system by which cable firms must provide their programming on third-party {hardware} by way of web protocols. The concept was that firms like Apple, Google, or Amazon may combine cable programming with their current streaming gamers, offering freedom from rental charges together with modern options like voice management.
Naturally, the TV trade hated this idea, and so it got here up with a counter-proposal: Instead of letting gadget makers combine cable content material nonetheless they needed, the trade supplied to supply its personal apps on virtually any streaming gadget. That approach, prospects would get to decide on their very own {hardware}, however the TV trade would nonetheless retain some management.
In the top, neither proposal occurred. When Ajit Pai took over the FCC in 2017, sidelining Wheeler’s cable field guidelines was among his first orders of business. And with out the specter of regulation, the trade quietly abandoned its alternative app-based scheme.
In explaining why it killed off Wheeler’s plan for good final week, the FCC largely regurgitated cable trade speaking factors. The company stated it had “serious and unresolved concerns” about safety and copyright safety (considerations that shopper advocacy teams have disputed), and reiterated the identical argument it used towards CableCARD: Customers have already got the power to observe cable programming on their streaming units, so there’s no want for extra regulatory intervention.
Why cable field competitors nonetheless issues
There’s only one drawback with that argument: Streaming apps aren’t almost as prevalent because the FCC claims.
Sure, in case you’re a Comcast subscriber, you should utilize the Xfinity Stream app in place of a cable box on Roku units, Samsung TVs, and LG TVs. But that very same app isn’t accessible on different streaming platforms resembling Apple TV, Amazon Fire TV, Android TV, or Chromecast. A report final yr by FinestAppleTV claimed that Comcast is extra involved in increase its personal X1 platform than supporting extra third-party alternate options resembling Apple TV, and whereas Comcast disputed the story, it hasn’t launched any new streaming apps in additional than a yr.
Likewise, in case you’re getting TV service by way of Spectrum, you should utilize the Spectrum app on Roku, Apple TV, Samsung TVs, and Xbox One consoles, however not on Fire TV, Android TV, or Chromecast. Meanwhile, Dish Network solely presents reside TV and DVR on Amazon Fire TV units.
Jared Newman / TechHiveSpectrum presents apps on some streaming units, however not others.
And in case you’re a buyer of Verizon Fios, DirecTV, or Cox, you’re merely out of luck for changing your cable containers with streaming gamers. None of these suppliers provide their very own apps for streaming on TVs. You’re as an alternative restricted to streaming on telephones, tablets, and computer systems, or utilizing a patchwork of particular person TV community apps to entry programming.
Despite this clear failure by the trade to supply true cable field alternate options on all the most important streaming platforms, the FCC quotes the trade commerce group NCTA as saying its mission is completed, as a result of the 9 largest TV suppliers “support apps that can be used to watch their content on hundreds of millions of consumer-owned devices.” While that is likely to be technically true, it distorts the truth that streaming gadget help is wildly inconsistent throughout the board.
And though live TV streaming services resembling YouTube TV and Hulu + Live TV do present alternate options to cable and satellite tv for pc TV, their channel lineups are totally different, they usually require quick and dependable web service, which not everybody can get. Meanwhile, widespread enforcement of data caps can restrict how a lot video cord-cutters can stream over the web with out paying steep overage charges. (Pai’s FCC, by the way, has declined to do anything about data caps, even after they hinder competitors and stifle innovation.)
For individuals who can’t or gained’t minimize the twine, renting fewer set-top containers ought to signify a simple method to hold prices down. But neither TV trade nor the present FCC have a lot curiosity in ensuring prospects can do this.
Sign up for Jared’s Cord Cutter Weekly newsletter to get this column and different cord-cutting information, insights, and offers delivered to your inbox.