How a lot do you really want to spend on a brand new turntable? As I’ve discovered from our critiques of file gamers from $100 to $1000, there are nice merchandise at each stage — however like most issues in life, paying extra will provide you with extra. If you’ll be able to cut up the distinction and spend round $500, some glorious designs exist on the market to tempt any vinyl fan. One of my new favorites is the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO.
LikeSuberb options for the moneySweet, even-handed soundSolid construct qualityAvailable in 9 colours
Don’t LikeUnusual tonearm ergonomicsSounds much less thrilling than the Fluance RT85
I in contrast the EVO to a different turntable on this worth vary, the Fluance RT85. Both outdo cheaper fashions with strong construct high quality and step-up options, however in the long run I most well-liked the Pro-Ject over the Fluance — it sounded extra musical and felt extra pleasing to make use of. The EVO combines glorious playback high quality with a number of extras that you just will not see even on some more-expensive gamers just like the Rega Planar 3. The unique Debut Carbon has loved accolades ever since its look over ten years in the past. The new EVO model ($500, £449 and AU$879) is a worthy replace and among the finest methods to spend up on a file participant.
Are we not males? We are EVO!
Ty Pendlebury/CNET
The Pro-Ject Debut Carbon EVO packs within the audiophile-friendly options. It features a one-piece carbon-fiber tonearm, adjustable ft and an digital pace choice (no extra eradicating the platter, extra on that shortly). In addition, Pro-Ject presents 9 totally different end choices, together with forest inexperienced and canary yellow. My overview pattern got here in high-gloss crimson.The turntable features a suspension system borrowed from the higher-end X1, supporting a hefty 3.7-pound aluminum platter. The platter has been dampened with TPE (thermoplastic elastomer) lining the sting, which contributes to the turntable’s spectacular weight. Rapping with a knuckle on the platter nonetheless made it resonate nevertheless, even with the felt slipmat on, and particularly in the direction of the center. Doing the identical factor on the Fluance’s acrylic platter did not ring in any respect.
Ty Pendlebury/CNET
In the US the EVO comes pre-mounted with the Sumiko Rainier phono cartridge (little brother to the Olympia), whereas within the UK and Australia it is fitted with the Ortofon 2M Red. Note that each one of my listening assessments under had been of the US model; the UK and Australia variations will sound totally different.
Though the carbon fiber tonearm appears spiffy, the truth that it is one piece could make it a bit extra awkward to make use of. The finger raise (the jutty-out bit on the finish of the tonearm) is a bit too flat and broad, making it trickier to seize than different fashions. The Pro-Ject offers with pace modifications in an revolutionary means: with a three-way energy rocker tucked beneath the plinth. The three positions — Left 33 ⅓rpm, Center Off and Right 45rpm — aren’t marked nevertheless, so you will must train your muscle reminiscence when turning on the participant.The turntable comes with two cables. One is flat, which you will in all probability use all the time, and the second is a rounded cable for individuals who have previous 78s. The firm additionally contains an admittedly engaging RCA cable within the field, however tweakers should need to improve to a greater one later.Yo DJ spin that wheelTactility — eradicating the file from its sleeve, placing it on the platter, selecting up the tonearm, putting the needle within the groove — is arguably greater than half of the expertise once you’re enjoying information. The Pro-Ject might not fairly really feel like true a high-end participant, however it was positively extra enjoyable to make use of than the Fluance. Compared to the Fluance’s plastic-y lever the Pro-Ject’s knobbed lever felt a bit extra such as you’d count on in a product costing half a grand. If you have not used a Pro-Ject ‘desk earlier than, the way in which you must relaxation the tonearm vertically takes some getting used to — you’ll be able to’t simply swing the arm again over to the fitting. When the 2 turntables had been truly spinning information, it was the Pro-Ject that that the majority intently evoked the spirit of listening to vinyl. It had a relaxed, full presentation that wasn’t as tiring because the Fluance may very well be.
Ty Pendlebury/CNET
The Ortofon 2M Blue that comes with the Fluance is an exciting-sounding cartridge, and with the fitting materials it may possibly make you need to rise up and dance. Compared to the Pro-Ject’s stately efficiency, Velvet Underground by Jonathan Richman gave the impression of a very totally different recording on the Fluance– bass was deeper, tambourine crisper and there was a larger diploma of slapback echo from the fitting channel. By the identical token the Fluance can sound too ahead with some tracks, whereas the Pro-Ject presents extra of a way of house, which is particularly nice for large room seems like Nils Frahm’s Spaces. The Pro-Ject enhanced the file’s ambient qualities, making the room look like it prolonged deep into the house in entrance of me. The Fluance made the recording sound extra detailed however it was additionally two dimensional — it appeared to exist solely on the aircraft between the audio system. Spaces just isn’t precisely an edge-of-your-seat sort of recording, so the Pro-Ject’s extra relaxed method labored higher right here.I heard the Fluance’s forwardness once more on Nick Cave’s Red Right Hand, and right here the bass additionally threatened to change into boomy. Unless you have got a mellow sounding system, the Fluance RT85 looks as if one improve too far. The OM10 cartridge within the less-expensive Fluance RT82 is a nicely balanced cartridge, however the step as much as the 2M Blue within the RT85 can be an excessive amount of for already-bright techniques. The Pro-Ject once more confirmed higher steadiness and a finely honed delineation between Cave’s baritone and the deep bassline. I attempted my reference Rega Planar 3 with the Ortofon 2M Blue and whereas it supplied a equally ahead steadiness it was extra tempered, not steely just like the Fluance may very well be. The Pro-Ject with its Sumiko Rainier nonetheless sounded higher, nevertheless. And once I switched the Rega’s cartridge to the Goldring E3, I once more most well-liked the Pro-Ject, which demonstrates how tightly built-in the EVO’s cartridge/turntable mixture is.Should you purchase it?The Pro-Ject EVO presents glorious playback, appears nice and is loads of enjoyable to make use of. It’s constructed nicely and the flexibility to regulate the ft makes leveling a painless course of. The EVO is probably not good — the ergonomics of the tonearm take a bit getting used to, for instance — however that is nonetheless a good way to get again into vinyl, or to improve from a starter desk.