Home Gaming Skull and Bones review: less Black Flag, more red flags | Digital Trends

Skull and Bones review: less Black Flag, more red flags | Digital Trends

Skull and Bones review: less Black Flag, more red flags | Digital Trends

Skull and Bones
MSRP $70.00

“Skull and Bones turns the Golden Age of Piracy, one of the most exciting periods in history, into a mundane and plodding experience.”


Exciting naval fight

Good number of ships

Top-notch visuals and efficiency


Mundane duties

Mechanics don’t really feel totally fleshed out

Uncompelling late-game actions

Weak narrative and characters

Skull and Bones is Ubisoft’s long-awaited massively multiplayer on-line (MMO), open-world journey sport set throughout the Golden Age of Piracy. “Long-awaited” is an understatement, on condition that it’s been delayed quite a few occasions all through its decade-long improvement cycle. Now, we’re lastly within the homestretch, previous its conceptualization as a follow-up to Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag and quite a few modifications,
Touted by Ubisoft CEO Yves Guillemot as a “quadruple-A title” and with a dozen studios showing within the opening credit, Skull and Bones’ maiden voyage has all of the pomp imaginable. Yet,this journey could as effectively be its final. After taking part in the Skull and Bones open beta and the launch construct, I can say that this could be one of the vital disappointing main releases in current reminiscence.
That’s to not say that the long-delayed Skull and Bones is a catastrophe. Naval battles are thrilling, and it’s a visible spectacle with standout ship designs, settlements, and visible results which might be masterfully rendered to create a cinematic expertise. Everything else, although, comes with a caveat. A slew of questionable design selections sink what might have been an excellent pirate sport into one other weak live-service sport in a sea stuffed with them.
Lords of the excessive seas
Skull and Bones’ story begins when my ship is sunk by a hostile fleet. Landless (and rudderless), I’m instructed of Sainte-Anne, a pirate haven the place I can begin anew. It’s there the place I meet John Scurlock, the kingpin of Sainte-Anne. It’s a enjoyable idea, however one Skull and Bones doesn’t capitalize on. Instead, it fumbles the thought of an journey sport set throughout the Golden Age of Piracy. The core gameplay loop consists of acquiring quests from Scurlock and different NPCs, accumulating crafting supplies for ships and weapons, and roaming round whereas attempting to sink naval craft alongside the way in which.
Havens and settlements merely act as locations the place I purchase stuff or decide up quests. There’s no system the place I can recruit crewmates or seek for proficient officers (i.e., quartermaster, cook dinner, or boatswain). The means of gathering sources, in the meantime, is relegated to a minigame the place I click on on the mouse when it’s within the “green zone” of the meter.
Barring Scurlock and some others, most NPCs are simply distributors or quest givers which might be utterly devoid of persona. Combine these with a threadbare narrative that hardly will get off the bottom, and the premise of being a swashbuckling hero falls flat slightly abruptly. I felt no connection in any respect to my character. I wasn’t taking part in as a pirate; I used to be taking part in as a pirate ship.
Buccaneers and increase photographs
Though its story is missing, Skull and Bones provides a real cinematic expertise with its thrilling naval engagements. While aboard my vessel, I’d search out AI-controlled ships by decreasing the sails to catch the wind, steadily depleting my crew’s stamina within the course of. I’d hearth off long-distance photographs, then carry out tight turns for broadside volleys, earlier than arming torpedoes from my ship’s stern. Ship controls are easy, responsive, and straightforward sufficient to get used to. Item utilization, like restore kits to revive my hull’s hit factors or cooked meals to replenish the crew’s stamina, require only a fast motion wheel button press.
Chasing down a goal throughout stormy seas is as exhilarating as you possibly can think about.

The robust battle loop is additional helped by quite a lot of ship choices. All gamers begin out with the Dhow, a small craft that’s principally used to hunt for sharks and different animals, earlier than acquiring the Bedar. From there, it’s as much as you to amass sources and acquire Infamy (akin to expertise factors) by finishing quests and sinking enemies. Infamy rank-ups then unlock extra ship and weapon blueprints that you could buy from NPCs.
Mid- to late-game choices embrace the explosive specialist Padewakang and speedy Brigantine (each of that are my go-to picks), in addition to the tank-like Snow and hearth attack-focused Sambuk. There are a wealth of armaments to select from, too, permitting gamers to combine and match weapons for his or her ship’s loadout. I can shoot foes from afar with lengthy weapons or ballistae, deal area-of-effect (AoE) harm with bombards and mortars, or ram straight into hostiles earlier than torching them with sea fires.
Still, even when naval fight is Skull and Bones’ one true spotlight, there have been a number of key issues. The most evident is that boarding actions are simply fast cutscenes and there’s no melee fight — one thing that Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag supplied a toon of a decade in the past. Many enemies don’t have survival instincts both, as they’d proceed aggressively attacking even with low hull well being. There have been additionally moments when ship AI stopped working correctly, comparable to once I confronted the Maangodin, a ghost ship that’s hidden within the mists. I anticipated an epic combat, just for the Maangodin to spin round in place with out capturing me.
The reverse will be mentioned of mercenaries from the Rogues faction, which spawn at any time when there are gamers which might be enterprise late-game Helm provide runs (extra on these later). These opponents assault all gamers, so it’s doable to see a few of them gunning down hapless newcomers who’re nearly to depart the Sainte-Anne hub.
The captain’s guidelines
The world of Skull and Bones could be huge, however its targets are as mundane as will be. That’s primarily because of a tally- or checklist-style strategy. Early on, I’m loaded up with quests to destroy X variety of ships or acquire Y quantity of sources. That’s a advantageous loop, however one which repeats itself. When I head to a different island, I understand that my duties are comparable, however with several types of ships or sources. It’s additionally doable for a similar actual goal to reappear a number of hours later, whether or not from the identical vendor NPC or a brand new one.
Even looking for buried treasure in some way turns into a forgettable job. It entails crusing to a location, checking an illustration for an object that has a logo, and in search of a glowing gentle that permits you to dig for the chest. There aren’t any peculiar mysteries or intricate riddles concerned.
The journey is predominantly set within the Indian Ocean, the place a number of factions vie for management. Though, curiously sufficient, there’s no approach to work for these factions (i.e., no built-in repute system or mission checklist). I believe again to Sid Meier’s Pirates!, which allowed me to grow to be a privateer for rival nations, going as far as to assert settlements on their behalf. That’s a remake launched in 2004, and but its personal programs felt extra fleshed out than what’s explored right here.
It appears that my cats have a good higher reminiscence than the ocean’s best pirates.

At finest, you possibly can ransack and plunder the settlements of different factions in Skull and Bones. That exercise will get tedious too, because it follows a repetitive course of the place I simply destroy cannons and sink a handful of ships that are available waves. If only a few seconds elapse, the factions flip impartial once more, as if they utterly forgot the atrocities that I’ve simply dedicated. It appears that my cats have a good higher reminiscence than the ocean’s best pirates.
The Kingpin’s buying and selling empire
I particularly started to disconnect from Skull and Bones’ marketing campaign as a complete when it launched its endgame actions: the Helm Empire. This acts because the long-term engagement loop, the place you acquire and ship illicit cargo comparable to alcohol and medicines. The quest chain itself triggers independently of Scurlock’s arc. The objectives are to finish extra provide runs, get rid of ships from the Rogues faction alongside the way in which, and earn Pieces of Eight forex used for seasonal upgrades and objects.
When I attempted to go it alone, I used to be at an obstacle.

There are additionally world occasions that operate as PvPvE actions, like Legendary Heists the place you are taking out a “cannon sponge” goal, and the one who dealt essentially the most harm tries to flee with the reward. Naturally, these not in that participant’s group would do their finest to chase them down. Similarly, there are Hostile Takeovers, the place squadrons try to seize factories that passively grant Pieces of Eight.
Skull and Bones’ PvPvE endgame provides little or no to maintain solo gamers engaged for longer durations. I attempted out a few of these actions, however they really feel higher fitted to two- or three-player co-op. Settlement and ship targets are extraordinarily powerful to solo, and it’s doable to come across small co-op teams defending each other throughout heists. When I attempted to go it alone, I used to be at an obstacle. My solely recourse was to stay to the availability runs, and people duties turned monotonous after having already spent nearly all of the marketing campaign doing the identical issues again and again.
After taking part in Skull and Bones for 20 or so hours, I’ve discovered that there are some thrills available on the excessive seas. Naval battles definitely left me awestruck; ships explode in a wonderful spectacle in case you hit their weak spots, and the sensation of chasing down a goal throughout stormy seas is as exhilarating as you possibly can think about. Performance with my PC {hardware} — an Nvidia RTX 3080, Intel i9-10900Ok, and 32 GB of RAM — was additionally top-notch, as I used to be capable of play on the highest settings with hardly any egregious body fee drops or stutters. Regrettably, Skull and Bones’ boring story, tedious quest targets, questionable design selections, and a poorly tuned expertise for solo gamers made me furl the sails and return to shore as a landlubber.
Skull and Bones was reviewed on PC. The code was offered by the writer.

Editors’ Recommendations