In February 2018, Google made a daring proclamation: It was able to “raise the bar of excellence for enterprise devices and services,” and it was launching a brand new program known as Android Enterprise Recommended to make that occur.The program, in response to Google, would set up “best practices and common requirements for devices and services, backed by a thorough testing process” performed by Google itself. It would be certain that any gadgets with the Android Enterprise Recommended stamp of approval would obtain well timed and dependable software program updates, amongst different issues — together with assist of the present Android model and supply of all safety patches inside 90 days of their launch for at least three years.And all of that was solely purported to be the beginning: “With each new Android platform release, we will update the Android Enterprise Recommended program requirements and continue to raise the bar to ensure we are delivering the best experience for our enterprise customers,” Google promised on the time.So now, practically two and a half years later, how has the Android Enterprise Program held up? Has it flourished and was the dependable useful resource it was meant to be — a spot the place critical enterprise customers can transfer previous the mass of Android system choices and discover distinctive telephones with optimum privateness, safety, and efficiency protections?As you’ll be able to most likely guess from the title of this story, the reply is a convincing “no.” The nearer you have a look at the Android Enterprise Recommended program, actually, the more severe it seems. And from the appears of it, issues are about to go downhill even additional.Android Enterprise Recommended guarantees vs. realityAt its core, the Android Enterprise Recommended program is an awfully wise concept. Android, as everyone knows by now, is an open platform — and meaning there’s plenty of range and variance within the types of experiences you get from one system to a different. That’s particularly important in terms of software program and safety, as we have mentioned numerous instances over time.So fairly than let individuals guess or be pressured to depend on the analysis and evaluation of lowly writers like yours really — which is what usually occurs with Android cellphone purchases, since device-makers are something however upfront about their practices surrounding post-sales software program assist — Google determined to create its personal business-focused useful resource. After all, what IT division would not need a spot that’d make it simple to know which gadgets might be trusted to take safety significantly?The entire factor definitely sounds spectacular. But then you definately go to take a look at the gadgets Google is definitely recommending, and — nicely…GoogleThe very first cellphone listed on the Android Enterprise Recommended Devices web page is the Motorola-made Moto Z4 — a cellphone that is “validated by Google” for assembly its “highest standards,” with “regular security updates guaranteed.”Now for the reality-checking distinction: The Moto Z4 cellphone acquired the present Android 10 launch 189 days late — this previous March, greater than six months after the software program really got here out. That unacceptably poor efficiency earned the corporate a giant fats 0% “F” on my newest Android Upgrade Report Card. And in case you assume full-fledged OS updates don’t have anything to do with the important areas of privateness, safety, and efficiency, assume once more. They’re each bit as vital because the month-to-month safety patches that fill within the gaps between their releases.As for these patches, the Moto Z4’s historical past on that entrance is not significantly better: According to a database maintained by the web site Android Police, the Z4 went with none safety updates from July to November of final 12 months — after which bought a November replace that was already two months outdated. The web site’s information signifies that the Moto Z4 has missed eight patches solely since its arrival and that it is “more likely for Z4 owners to not get an update at all.” The cellphone earned a two out of 10 rating in its rating.And that is an Android Enterprise Recommended product — one the place “you get timely security patches and major updates guaranteed” to be able to “ensure devices stay safe and current.”How does any of this gel with the essential premise of what Android Enterprise Recommended is meant to be?Lest you assume that is only a random anomaly, whenever you look via the entire listing of Android Enterprise Recommended gadgets, you see numerous equally puzzling merchandise — just like the also-Motorola-made Moto Z3 Play, which got here out in the summertime of 2018, acquired Android 9 an embarrassing 295 days late, and nonetheless hasn’t gotten Android 10, practically 10 and a half months after that software program’s launch.On the safety replace entrance, person experiences point out a combined bag for the Z3 Play, with some updates arriving inside a month or so of their launch and others by no means exhibiting up — in some instances with a number of months going by with nary an replace and a irritating lack of expertise obtainable in regards to the system’s assist standing.The official Enterprise Recommended listing consists of curiously dated gadgets, too, just like the BlackBerry KeyOne — a cellphone that got here out in April of 2017, acquired an replace to Android 8 practically a 12 months after the actual fact, and by no means bought up to date to Android 9, not to mention Android 10. The KeyOne hasn’t acquired a safety replace since mid-2019, and the BlackBerry model is now not even related to the third-party firm that made the cellphone and stays liable for its assist.How does any of that gel with the essential premise of what the Android Enterprise Recommended program is meant to be and the precise, “strict” necessities of the expertise its authorized gadgets are promised to offer?The brief reply is easy: It does not. And from the appears of it, Google could also be all too conscious of those failings and dealing to right this system’s course — however not with the kind of repair you’d logically anticipate to see.The way forward for Android Enterprise RecommendedWhen device-makers aren’t maintaining with their finish of the discount and the listing of Google-approved telephones is laughably removed from assembly this system’s fundamental guarantees, you’d assume the reply could be to re-emphasize the necessities, push producers to comply with them, and minimize the listing of authorized gadgets down solely to those who comply — proper?That’d definitely make sense. But it seems that Google could also be entering into a special course and as a substitute scaling again the necessities of its Android Enterprise Recommended program to be able to make them simpler to fulfill.A set of paperwork reportedly shared with distributors (and printed initially by the web site XDA Developers) means that as of Android 11, Google will revise the Enterprise Recommended pointers to fully take away the assure of getting all safety updates inside 90 days of their launch together with the assure of three full years of dependable safety patches. Instead, the paperwork point out, device-makers will likely be required solely to offer “Emergency Security Maintenance Release” updates — presumably these which might be deemed to be notably important and urgent.The one optimistic is that as a part of the change, the paperwork say makers of Android Enterprise Recommended gadgets will must be extra clear about their OS and safety replace plans — making it potential for potential purchasers to see precisely how lengthy any given cellphone will likely be supported with updates in addition to how usually these updates will arrive.That’s unbelievable and one thing that ought to occur universally, throughout all of Android, so that everybody could make an informed determination primarily based on official software program assist data. But it completely should not be a alternative for the cheap requirement of offering well timed and dependable updates on gadgets which might be introduced as being optimally updated, safe, and acceptable for enterprise use. What occurred to “raising the bar” with every new launch to make sure “the best experience” for enterprise prospects?I reached out to Google to verify the main points talked about within the paperwork — and whereas the corporate notably did not take the chance to disclaim the authenticity of any of the data, it additionally declined to share any remark or express affirmation.Regardless, although, whereas the potential for this system’s necessities to be weakened even additional is regarding, the truth is that even in its present state, Google’s Android Enterprise Recommended program is completely meaningless. Instead of being a information to totally vetted, exceptionally supported gadgets, it is in the end only a random listing of telephones — most of which are not being up to date commonly and plenty of of which are actually so dated that their inclusion is nearly comical.So if you cannot depend on these official suggestions, what are you able to do? That reply, fortunately, is definitely fairly easy.The chilly, exhausting Android replace truthI’ve mentioned it earlier than, and I’ll say it once more: If you need the very best person expertise on Android and a cellphone that is assured to stay optimally updated and with the strongest privateness, safety, and efficiency protections potential, Google’s self-made Pixel telephones are the one totally advisable choices it’s best to contemplate. They use Google’s personal core Android software program, with out the interface-muddying and typically privacy-jeopardizing modifications different producers like to make, and so they reliably obtain all software program updates inside days of their launch, instantly from Google, for a full three years from their launch dates.No matter what narrative chances are you’ll hear about upgrades enhancing and sure different corporations getting considerably higher at offering them, the truth is that no different device-maker even comes near Google’s personal commonplace. I’m optimistic that Microsoft’s arrival within the Android area later this 12 months may change that, however for now, the Pixel line is the one path with any sort of elevated software program assist assure and historical past of persistently well timed replace deliveries.The one different chance price contemplating is a cellphone related to Google’s Android One program, which is nearly like a much less publicized, lower-end model of what the Enterprise Recommended program is supposed to be. Android One telephones additionally use Google’s personal Android software program and are assured to get moderately well timed OS updates for 2 years from their launch dates together with month-to-month safety updates for 3. Those updates usually arrive considerably later than what you’d see with a Pixel, nevertheless it’s sometimes a delay of some months at most as a substitute of “indefinite,” as is commonly the case with different gadgets. (Just you should definitely search for when any system really launched — whether or not it is a Pixel or an Android One cellphone — and contemplate that prior to creating a purchase order, as that date will let you know how lengthy the cellphone’s been out and thus how lengthy is left in its energetic assist interval.)I’d like to see Google pivot away from this Android Enterprise Recommended mess and as a substitute provide an “Android Pro”-style subscription that’d higher emphasize Pixel telephones as one of the best all-around choices for companies and anybody else critical about safety after which permit customers to pay a month-to-month charge to make sure they’re at all times utilizing an optimally up-to-date system. Maybe sooner or later.For now, although, if you’d like what the Android Enterprise Recommended program pretends to offer, it’s best to disregard that effort solely and as a substitute have a look at Pixel or Android One gadgets. As it stands, the Android Enterprise Recommended program is little greater than a deceptive disservice — and the neatest factor you are able to do is ignore it, lest you be led astray.Sign up for my weekly e-newsletter to get extra sensible ideas, private suggestions, and plain-English perspective on the information that issues.[Android Intelligence videos at Computerworld]
Copyright © 2020 IDG Communications, Inc.